"A handsome, compact, efficient building" says commenter

In this week's comments update, readers are discussing a school in Canterbury completed by Walters & Cohen with a material palette of flint, oak and limestone.

Located alongside an entrance to Canterbury's cathedral precincts, The Rausing Science Centre was designed to balance a traditional material palette with a "crisp and contemporary" approach.

"What a thoughtful and pleasant design" 

Readers were impressed."Beautiful execution and attention to detail – magnificent!" wrote Jerry Dickman-Wilkes.

"What a thoughtful and pleasant design," agreed The Truth. They went on to say that "this sort of respect for scale, context and materiality is not often seen in contemporary additions."

"Fancy that – a handsome, compact, efficient building, constructed of quality materials, with no arbitrary angles", commented Karl. Also a fan of the design was Souji, calling it "very nice, a step in the right direction".

One reader who wasn't so sure was Chris, who interjected "I dig the materiality, but it looks like a village building shoehorned into an academic campus – odd."

What do you make of it? Join the discussion ›

"Back to the essentials! Beautiful and simple details"

Also providing plenty of fodder for the comments section this week was a skyscraper with a green-pigmented concrete facade and a series of cantilevers, completed by local studio Adamo Faiden in Buenos Aires, Argentina.

Johan thought the building was "quite elegant and a lovely shade of green" and that it "works very nicely with the historic warehouses."

"Back to the essentials! Beautiful and simple details," praised Matheus Seco, adding "what a superb building!"

But not all commenters were quite so smitten, with Idracula deciding "from a distance, graphically interesting...up close, pretty banal."

Also unconvinced, Souji called it "oppressive and inelegant", concluding "meh, more of the same mediocre stuff we are used to."

Meanwhile, commenter John-in-Melbourne was "not sure it fits in with the landscape around it".

Have you had your say? Join the discussion ›

"Trying to please everyone and exciting no one"

Readers were largely unimpressed by Snøhetta's headquarters for automotive company Ford in Michigan, which features an engineering-focused central building.

"Clean! Bright! Umm and sterile," commented Rickboxer. "How about even a dab of colour somewhere?" they asked.

On the same page was Alfred Hitchcock, arguing "it's nicely polished, but it's like Ford's cars – trying to please everyone and exciting no one." They branded it "middle of the road stuff".

"A mess and a bore", contributed Souji, while JZ thought "it feels massively generic".

Do you agree? Join the discussion ›

Comments update

Dezeen is the world's most commented architecture and design magazine, receiving thousands of comments each month from readers. Keep up to date on the latest discussions on our comments page and subscribe to our weekly Debate newsletter, where we feature the best reader comments from stories in the last seven days.

The post "A handsome, compact, efficient building" says commenter appeared first on Dezeen.